Khama ndiye yankho poweta ng’ombe zamkaka
Kuchionetsero cha zaulimi cha National Agriculture Fair ku Trade Fair Grounds mumzinda wa Blantyre, Peacewell Edward Mlanga, wochokera kwa Senior...
Chisamaliro choyenera cha ng’ombe za mkaka
Ngakhale alimi ambiri a ng’ombe za mkaka amabwekera kuti akupeza phindu ku ulimiwu, Jacob Mwasinga, mlangizi wa ziweto ku Mzuzu...
‘Nandolo wa makono ndiye yankho’
Ngakhale mitengo ya nandolo siyinali bwino kwenikweni chaka chatha, Jonath Goliath wa m’boma la Neno akuti adachita mphumi popeza...
Kudya moyenera n’kofunika
Kudya ndi moyo koma woona za kadyedwe koyenera ku Lilongwe University of Agriculutre and Natural Resources (Luanar), Dr Alexander...
Nandolo mpatali
Ubwino wa nandolo si uli pa kupeza ndalama zochuluka kokha komanso zina zambiri, watero mkulu woona za mbewu za...
Households to benefit from nutrition project
About 26 000 households will benefit from a K1.2 billion project aimed at improving the health of people in...
![The High Court in Lilongwe has reserved its ruling on whether former president Peter Mutharika and former Secretary to President and Cabinet Lloyd Muhara should personally pay costs for judges’ forced leave and retirement case.
Mutharika and Muhara were earlier faulted by the court for forcing Chief Justice Andrew Nyirenda and Justice Edward Twea to go on leave pending retirement.
Yesterday the court heard arguments from Mutharika and Muhara’s lawyers as well as from lawyers for Malawi Law Society (MLS), Human Rights Defenders Coalition (HRDC) and Association of Magistrates in Malawi, who are demanding that the two foot the legal costs.
High Court Judge Charles Mkandawire adjourned the case pending ruling.
The court will set a date to determine if Mutharika and Muhara should personally pay the costs.
Mutharika and Muhara’s lawyer Mwayi Banda said under Section 91(3) of the Republican Constitution, the President, after his term of office, shall not be personally held liable for actions which were done in an official capacity while he was President.
“These acts were done in an official capacity, why should he [Mutharika] be liable. The President is not liable as an individual but the Office of the President is the one that is liable,” he said.
Banda added that it is not automatic that when a public official is found to have been negligent then he should be held liable.
He said there are many instances, including the May 2019 presidential election case where the court did not order officials to meet costs personally.
On Muhara, Banda said as Secretary to President and Cabinet, he was only communicating a decision made by Cabinet and there was no point in holding him accountable.
“He was only a mouthpiece. Should you really punish a mouth piece and not the office from which the decisions were coming?” he said.
However, MLS lawyer Wesley Mwafulirwa said presidential immunity does not apply in the issue of personal cost orders. He said a President should act within the law.
He said the same Constitution that protects the President should be upheld as no one is above the law, adding that ordering payment of costs is court’s discretion and it can apply to anyone.
“Immunity does not cover personal cost orders of this nature and we believe that as MLS, we have a function under Section 64 of Legal Education and Legal Practitioners Act to protect matters of public interest of this nature,” said Mwafulirwa.
HRDC and Association of Magistrates in Malawi lawyer Khumbo Soko also said the same Constitution that protects the President should be upheld all the time.
He said all the applicants want to ensure that leaders do not make unnecessary decisions.
Soko said the current case will set a precedent that if one makes unjustified decisions, they will be held accountable.
“The two made decisions that were unreasonable and unconstitutional. It would not be proper for taxpayers to meet the costs,” he said.
Prior to the June 23 Fresh Presidential Election, Muhara wrote Nyirenda and Twea to go on leave pending retirement.](https://www.mwnation.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Chidanti-Malunga-350x250.jpg)
Prosecute maize scam culprits now—MP
Following the adoption of the report on the Zambia maize inquiry by Parliament, chairperson for the Parliamentary Agriculture Committee,...
Student fears losing opportunity
Mwimba College of Agriculture student Andrew Phiri is appealing to well-wishers to help him pay K270 000 for tuition. Phiri,...
Pigeon peas fetch high price outside Malawi
Malawians who underwent various training programmes in Japan have committed themselves to complementing government efforts in raising financial and human...
Govt urges ‘varsities to promote research
Malawi is not faring well in promoting research and knowledge generation in its academic systems among the country’s institutions of...
Mpendadzuwa ungatukule malawi
Mkulu wa bungwe la Farmers Union of Malawi (FUM) Alfred Kapichira Banda, wati pakuyenera kukhala ndondomeko yabwino pakati pa...
TB ya kumsana imapha ziwalo
Dokotala wothandiza anthu omwe ali ndi vuto la kufa kwa ziwalo kuchipatala cha Kachere Rehabilitation Centre mumzinda wa Blantyre,...
Tsabola ndi waphindu, wophweka kulima
Ulimi wa tsabola umaoneka opanda pake komanso ogwetsa mphwayi, koma Benison Kuziona, mkulu wa Bungwe la Zikometso Innovation and...
Achenjeza zobzala chinangwa cha matenda
Katswiri oona za tizilombo toononga komanso toyambitsa matenda ku mbewu wa kunthambi ya kafukufuku ya Bvumbwe Research Station, Dr...
Kupewa kutsegula m’mimba
Nthenda ya kutsegula m’mimba ndi imodzi mwa matenda omwe amakonda kufala kwambiri m’nyengo ino ya mvula. Malinga...
Ulangizi paulimi mu 2016
Pamene tikulowa chaka chino mawa lino, ndi bwino tisanthule zina mwa nkhani zikuluzikulu komanso magawo amene tidakupatsirani mu Uchikumbe mu...
Fodya wobwerera kumsika amugulitsa
Mkulu wa bungwe la Tobacco Association of Malawi (Tama), Graham Kunimba, wati fodya yemwe anabwerera pamsika chaka chino tsopano amugulitsa....
