Court dismisses Murekezi extradition case
The Lilongwe Principal Resident Magistrate Court today dismissed the extradition case against suspected Rwandan genocide convict Vincent Murekezi.
Principal Resident Magistrate (PRM) Patrick Chilunga Chirwa cited a number of irregularities in the manner in which the State presented the case in court and failure by the State to satisfy the requirements for extradition to countries which have no bilateral treaties with Malawi.
However, Chirwa acknowledged that Malawi and Rwanda had demonstrated interest to have Murekezi extradited.
He emphasised that genocide is an extraditable offense, dismissing the defense, which had contended that it is not a relevant offense for extradition.
However, Chirwa agreed with the defense that Rwanda is not a designated country for extradition, and this makes it impossible for Malawi to extradite Murekezi.
He also stated that Malawi and Rwanda are not on a bilateral treaty; hence, the only way to transfer genocide suspects to their native countries is through the Minister of Home Affairs and Internal Security entering into arrangements with countries that are in bilateral treaties with countries where genocide crimes were committed.
Chirwa further disagreed with the State that under the London Scheme for Extradition, Customary and International Law and Malawi’s Extradition Act, Malawi is empowered to arrest and extradite people suspected to have committed genocide crimes in their native countries.
At this point, Chirwa said he was “baffled” to note that the minister did not take necessary steps to facilitate this extradition process.
“I therefore dismiss the case. The State is at liberty to regularise the process and bring the matter back [to court],” he said.
Defense lawyer Wapona Kita described the ruling as victory for justice.
On the other hand, senior chief state advocate Steven Kayuni said he would be consulting his superiors to chart the way forward.
Meanwhile, Chirwa is on February 18 2017 expected to deliver his judgment on a corruption case involving Murekezi and the then Malawi Revenue Authority (MRA) official Komani Nyasulu.
The two are said to have committed the case in 2008. Nyasulu, who was the principal offender, pleaded guilty to the charge and was handed a community service sentence.
Police arrested Murekezi on December 8 2016 after a grouping calling itself Concerned Citizens piled pressure on government to have the Rwandese extradited over genocide case.
The suspected fugitive offender has lived in Malawi Malawi since 2003. He initially applied for temporary residence permit after securing police clearance.
Is this Rwandan killer that untouchable?? Mxiii!!
The minister of home affairs should have acted with expediency. It would seem she dragged her feet.
It is surprising for the magistrate to ignore the issue raised by prosecution; “Both countries being the members of Commonwealth transfer or extradition of fugitives can be effected”.
Someone may ask, it the judge’s conclusion has anything to do with the 50million MK raised by other fugitives living in Malawi to protect their colleague? Obviously, this question is YES with such behaviour.
only the law and judiciary in malawi make such insensible judgements! they let a real murderer walk free and let the innocent people suffer in jail! like the case of three innocent young men that were sentenced to seven years in prison for a robbery which was infact done by some guys(which are currently in custody for other crimes), even with evidence brought forward but rejecting it. when will malawi ever jack the fuck up???