Saturday, January 23, 2021
  • About Us
  • ImagiNATION
  • Adverts
  • Rate Card
  • Contact Us
The Nation Online
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Life & Style
    • Every Woman
      • Soul
      • Family
    • Religion
    • Feature
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Chichewa
  • Enation
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Life & Style
    • Every Woman
      • Soul
      • Family
    • Religion
    • Feature
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Chichewa
  • Enation
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Columns My Turn

Playing with failure (II)

by Johnny Kasalika
22/03/2013
in My Turn
3 min read
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare on LinkedinLinkedinShare via Email

What happened? Were we duped? Were we somehow hoodwinked and did not know it? Or was it something else?

RelatedHeadlines

Framework for engaging retired experts

Why do national IDs expire?

Somaliland deserves recognition

We were neither duped nor hoodwinked. There are several reasons why the Play-Pump failed and they mostly categorised into three:

.Technically, the Play-Pump had an inherently complex design with pump parts that were either not readily available on the local market or too expensive. In this age of community-based management, where the onus for operating, maintaining and replacing water supply systems is shifting from government and NGOs to communities—this technical flaw made the Play-Pump unsustainable.

.Conceptually, the Play-Pump needed the play-energy of the children—meaning that the pump was dependent on children spinning the merry-go-round to pump water up into an elevated tank. What the designers did not count on was that the children would have to pump 27 hours a day to meet the minimum standard of 25 litres per person per day. The Play-Pump only managed an average of two litres per child per day.  

.Safety-wise, the Play-Pump proved dangerous to children with stories of children falling and hitting their heads on the concrete pavement. 

These are all correct and valid lessons to take from the Play-Pump’s monumental failure, but the real culprit of the Play-Pump’s failure is not really conceptual or technical—it is human. It is the very thing that was supposed to provide solutions to our water problems, but is ironically adding to them. And that “human thing” is the water sector itself. The water sector as a whole—donors, NGOs, bureaucrats, technocrats—we are all responsible for the failure of the Play-Pump!

As a sector, we do not think things through before implementation. We are very quick to sign off on policies and strategies that do not take into consideration the impact of the changes we intend to make on the existing complexities of human nature or community life. We seek out quick fixes that offer short-term relief, but secrete even larger problems in the future. We jump on any bandwagon that large NGOs and multilateral donors push without asking: Can this idea work for the Malawian context? Will it be sustainable?  What new problems could this idea potentially create because of its intrinsic nature/design?

Several NGOs and local experts started emerging out of the woodworks claiming to have foreseen the Play-Pump’s failure. I only wish these Monday Morning Coaches had said something on Sunday afternoon. 

Nobody did or said anything when it actually mattered! We just accepted what we got without asking any questions. And even when failures were imminent with the Play-Pump—we marched on believing in our naivety that we were doing our little part to change Malawi. As long as targets were being met, numbers were being reported, LOGFRAMEs were followed and donors were happy, there were no worries!

And, despite all good intent, the water sector, and how it works, becomes the very reason why water is not flowing. As our fancy “one size fits all” technical solutions continue to break down, frustrated communities remain, not just at risk of contracting life-threatening diseases but also at risk of remaining in a deficit mode of hopelessness, apathy and mistrust – a potent recipe for sluggish development in the long term.

The problem is not technology, it is the sector and how it works.

If we do not stop for a moment and reflect critically about the wider cycle of water-poverty and how our solutions, approaches and strategies are impacting, either negatively or positively, on it in the longer term, then we are doomed to fail again and again – no matter how many lessons we learn or how good our policy documents or ideas sound on paper.

So, join me as I raise a glass in acknowledgement of the failure we know as the Play-Pump. I hope it is pulled out from under the carpet, out from among the many unspoken and unholy failures of years-past and years-to-come, and given a high place of dishonour where people will see it for what it truly is: a reflection of us – water sector. –The author is grants manager for Water for People, writing in his personal capacity.

Previous Post

Uniting to save water

Next Post

Kinnah sends best wishes to Flames

Related Posts

My Turn

Framework for engaging retired experts

January 11, 2021
national id | The Nation Online
My Turn

Why do national IDs expire?

January 8, 2021
My Turn

Somaliland deserves recognition

January 1, 2021
Next Post
Kinnah phiri close mar23 | The Nation Online

Kinnah sends best wishes to Flames

Trending Stories

  • Not yet given retirement benefits: Mutharika

    Tonse faulted on former presidents’ benefits

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • FAM ex-co approves women’s national league

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Covid-19 initiative raises K18.3m in 2 days

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • High-profile official angered Wirima to quit

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Biden becomes 46th American President

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Opinions and Columns

These Freedoms

Where is God in the Malawi Vision 2063?

January 22, 2021
Business Unpacked

Towards Malawi2063, lessons from Vision 2020

January 20, 2021
Rise and Shine

Never give up on resolutions

January 20, 2021
In pursuit of development

India’s vaccine drive

January 20, 2021
  • Values
  • Our Philosophy
  • Editorial policy
  • Advertising Policy
  • Code of Conduct
  • Plagiarism disclaimer
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use

© 2021 Nation Publications Limited. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Life & Style
    • Every Woman
      • Soul
      • Family
    • Religion
    • Feature
  • Society
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Chichewa
  • Enation

© 2020 Nation Publications Limited. All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.